Strategy Comparison

O'Neil vs Minervini

Stop loss, break even & profit taking rules — side by side.

William O'Neil
Mark Minervini
Shared rule
Rule William O'Neil Mark Minervini
Stop Loss
Max loss per trade −7% to −8% −7% to −10%
Stop placement Below pivot / base Below support / 50-day MA
Capital at risk ≤ 1–2% 0.5–2%
Break Even
Move stop to entry +10% to +12% +10% to +15%
Profit Taking
Primary target +20% to +25% +20% to +25%
Partial profits ⅓ position at +15–20% Scale out on strength
Special rule 8-week hold if +20% in 1–3 weeks
exceptional strength
Pyramid into winners
never add to losers
Trailing stop MA, support, etc. MA, support, etc.
Choppy Markets
Stop loss −5% to −6% −5% to −6%
Profit target Take profits faster
don't wait for 20–25%
Take profits faster
don't wait for 20–25%
Philosophy
Stock selection CANSLIM
fundamental + technical
SEPA
technical-first
Market timing Critical — bull markets only Important — more flexible
Min risk/reward 3 : 1 3 : 1
Relationship The teacher The student who evolved it
⚡ Sell Before Your Stop Minervini only
The stop loss is the absolute maximum you're willing to lose — not the target. If price action speaks negatively, Minervini doesn't wait for the stop to be hit. Exit is an active decision, not a passive one.

Early Exit Signals

  • Close at the day's low after a breakout
  • Heavy volume down — signals institutional selling, not profit-taking
  • Breakout fails to hold the buy point even intraday
  • Same-day reversal on breakout day (bought high, closed low)

The Logic

If the evidence that made you buy has already reversed, why wait for the stop? The stop exists for unexpected moves. When weakness is visible and logical, the exit is a conscious decision — not a waiting game.

Result Instead of −7%, exit at −2% or −3% — preserving capital for the next setup. Across dozens of trades, this makes an enormous difference to the overall outcome.

Core principle — cut losses short. Let winners run.